9 world changing moments from San Francisco’s history of sexual liberation
From gay liberation to non-monogamy and same-sex marriage, America’s sexual revolution came to the forefront in the 1960s, with much of it taking place within San Francisco. Since then, the city has solidified its standing as the world’s freedom pioneer, showing the power in simply getting naked and being unashamed.
Here are nine key moments and places that made San Francisco the envy of the world.
- Early Gay Bars
No city has as salacious a past as San Francisco — and we mean that in a good way. We're talking about early watering holes like The Dash. This establishment opened in 1908 and was almost immediately shuttered after a scandal involving a city judge propositioning the cross-dressing staff. Through the '30s, Finocchio’s and Mona’s were the place for drag acts, both for kings and queens.
When World War II broke out, soldiers traveling through Pacific ports stopped in San Francisco, where they availed themselves of this blossoming underground gay bar scene. It often centered around drag, but gradually spread to clubs catering to every slice of gay life. These places of infamy tended to be clustered around the Tenderloin and South of Market, decades before the Castro became the city’s queer epicenter.
- Weekly (Naked) Dances
Something about the combination of the city’s temperate climate and liberal climes made people want to take their clothing off, even in public. The city grappled for decades with how naked is too naked, and in the 1970s San Francisco passed a law banning nudity in public parks in response to a weekly dance circle that gathered in Speedway Meadow in Golden Gate Park. Citizen complaints resulted in a crackdown. The law was updated in 2012 to deal with random nude men and women who tend to roam the Castro for no apparent reason other than the spectacle of it. Even Folsom Street Fair has had to crack down on nudity and, well, public displays of affections; but the liberationist foundation remains stronger than ever.
The clothing-optional attitudes stem from the hippie movement of the 1960s, when thousands of counterculture youngsters flocked to the city to shed their parents' values along with their own inhibitions. Clustering primarily around the Haight, this movement culminated in the Summer of Love, and the impact reverberates today.
- The Human Be-In
The Summer of Love was launched by a few key events, particularly the “Human Be-In” in January 1967. The city had just banned LSD, so activists organized a massive event that drew tens of thousands of people to Golden Gate Park to protest in scantily clad outfits despite the winter chill. Mind-altering guru Timothy Leary spoke alongside Lawrence Ferlinghetti and Allen Ginsberg. The Grateful Dead opened for Jefferson Airplane. Whoa.
Everything about the hippies spoke freedom. They were liberal in their use of mind-altering substances, radical in their politics, daring in their fashion, and devoted to the greening of the environment before it was a necessity. They formed communes, wrote poetry, and threw off the clothing of a sexually repressed culture that seemed stuck in the 1950s.
- Recognizing Same-Sex Relationships
San Francisco paved the way in recognizing same-sex relationships, but it was a bumpy road. As early as 1979, employees in nearby Berkeley had proposed domestic partnership recognition. San Francisco Supervisor Harry Britt (above) took up the idea and was able to get it passed by the city's Board of Supervisors. By today’s standards, the law was limited, only extending certain health benefits to the partners of city employees. It was initially vetoed by Mayor (and future U.S. Senator) Dianne Feinstein, a late convert to equality, but it eventually passed and became law. In 2004, Mayor Gavin Newsom made worldwide news when he legalized same-sex marriage before it was overturned by California voters. Today, after the U.S. Supreme Court overturned bans on marriage equality, the city is a magnet for couples pledging their allegiance to each other inside City Hall and on the famous steps outside.
- Early Leather Bars
Growing out of a military aesthetic from World War II, the leather community quickly gained a foothold (among other holds) in San Francisco. The city hosted motorcycle clubs like Warlocks and California Motor, and much of the energy centered around a bar named Tool Box. This club featured an enormous mural of men in leather jackets. Featured in an issue of Life magazine, Tool Box brought awareness of the leather community to small-town gays who might never have otherwise known it existed. They ended up flocking to it. The bar was a predecessor to multiple SoMa leather bars, including Powerhouse, which thrives on Folsom Street to this day.
- The Council of the Summer of Love
In the late '60s, national attention brought an influx of hippies to the city. The swell in temporary residents was overwhelming, and so in 1969 residents formed “The Council of the Summer of Love” to make sure there was infrastructure, including a temporary house, for the wave of visitors.
It’s important to note just how sexually repressed American society was at the time. Colleges restricted housing by gender; contraception was difficult to broach in polite society; homosexuality was considered shocking and taboo. Out of that Summer of Love blossomed an unofficial, informal, decentralized phenomenon known as “free love.” A key tenet is the belief in love and sex without interference from peer pressure or outside institutions like marriage and the law.
This is as San Francisco as a movement can get! The city embraced personal freedom, welcoming anyone who wished to express themselves without fear of interference. Many Americans sought stability in the traditional family unit, but that also meant repressing any desires that existed outside of that unit. Starting in San Francisco in the '60s, young people found themselves ready to cast those rules aside.
- Compton’s Cafeteria Riot
Of particular note during the '60s was gay lib. Thought-leaders like Ginsberg, Gore Vidal and William S. Burroughs produced poetry and prose that celebrated same love. An article in Life highlighted the city’s culture of inclusion with a headline reading “Gay San Francisco,” declaring it “the gay capital of America.”
In 1966, police harassment provoked the first documented transgender riot in the United States. It was located at Compton’s Cafeteria in the Tenderloin, and led to the city’s creation of programs that brought trans people together with police so that they could collaborate on social services and coexist. The next year, Margo Rila and Frank Esposito formed the Sexual Freedom League in the city. And when the Summer of Love reached mainstream audiences around the world, it brought people face-to-face with gay couples for what was, for many, the first time. In February 2017 legislation was introduced before the San Francisco Board of Supervisors for consideration to create the nation's first transgender district, Compton's Transgender, Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual (TLGB) District in a portion of the Tenderloin;
- Folsom Street Fair
Just a year later, the Stonewall riots transformed liberation forever, thanks, in part, to the messages of tolerance and freedom espoused in San Francisco. During the late 1960s and early ’70s, the Castro became a cornerstone in the national LGBTQ rights movement. Organizers held Gay-Ins and organized a Gay Liberation Day that eventually became San Francisco Pride.
In the 1980s, the city’s kink community organized the first Folsom Street Fair, a celebration of bondage and leather. Initially, it was a protest against development of a neighborhood that had always been home to marginalized queer communities. The fair quickly became an international symbol of freedom, with visitors descending on the the event every September. It continues today as a non-profit, raising money to help underserved communities and drawing nearly a half million people annually.
- Invention of Safe Sex
San Francisco’s embrace of sexual diversity faced numerous challenges during the '80s, especially the HIV/AIDS backlash orchestrated by the religious right and the Reagan Administration. The crisis threw free love adherents into a panic. The city’s response to the epidemic was to force the closure of bathhouses, where the spread of HIV was thought to be endemic. (It also deprived the community of a place to educate men about safe sex practices.) Nevertheless, San Francisco quickly blazed a trail, creating the “condom code,” in which men were encouraged to have all the sex they wanted as long as they used a condom for intercourse, every time. A variety of frank, explicit education campaigns throughout the AIDS crisis helped the queer community understand the importance of protection, of testing, and of disclosing your status. Today, the city has launched a massive new project to “Get to Zero” new infections by the year 2020.